Thursday, June 11, 2009

"Publisher Appears to Have Accepted Fake Paper From Bogus Center." INSIDE HIGHER EDUCATION June 10, 2009.

It’s an especially bad time for a medical journal to be duped by an author who, say, submits a fake computer-generated research paper from a fake institution he named the Center for Research in Applied Phrenology — or CRAP. And yet that’s exactly what appears to have happened. The deception was the work of Philip M. Davis, a doctoral student in communication at Cornell University who serves as executive editor of the Society for Scholarly Publishing’s Scholarly Kitchen blog. Mr. Davis said he had concocted the plan after receiving numerous “aggressive” unsolicited e-mail messages from Bentham Publishing, which finances its line of 200 open-access scientific journals by charging authors a publication fee. Mr. Davis and the blog’s editor in chief, Kent R. Anderson, submitted two research papers that were created by a computer program at MIT called SCIgen that describes itself as generating random text intended to “maximize amusement, rather than coherence.” One of the papers was rejected by Bentham, and the other — a nonsensical five-page report with footnotes and graphical charts that purported to describe an Internet process called the “Trifling Thamyn” — was accepted after the publisher said it had been peer-reviewed. Mr. Davis reported that an invoice for $800 had been issued by Bentham, without any evidence that the article was actually peer-reviewed. . . . [I thought this sort of thing only happened with so-called Postmodernists and in the Humanities (see the Sokal Hoax)?] Read the rest here: http://chronicle.com/news/article/6613/open-source-publisher-is-found-to-have-accepted-fake-paper-from-bogus-center.

No comments:

Post a Comment